Prop Bets Explained: Betting on Individual Performances

Learn what prop bets are, the different types of player and game props, how they're priced, and what to know before betting them.

Prop bets (short for proposition bets) let you bet on specific outcomes within a game rather than the final result. Instead of picking who wins or what the total score is, you’re betting on things like “Will Patrick Mahomes throw for over 275.5 yards?” or “Will the first score be a touchdown?”

Props are the fastest-growing betting market in sports — and they come in a huge variety. If you’re new to betting, start with the basics first: spreads, moneylines, and totals.

Types of Prop Bets

Player Props

The most popular category. You’re betting on an individual player’s statistical performance.

Common player props by sport:

Sport Prop Categories
NFL Passing yards, rushing yards, receiving yards, touchdowns, completions, interceptions, receptions
NBA Points, rebounds, assists, three-pointers made, steals, blocks, points + rebounds + assists (PRA)
MLB Strikeouts (pitcher), hits, home runs, RBIs, total bases, runs scored
NHL Goals, assists, points, shots on goal, saves (goaltender)

Example:

Player Prop Line Odds
Josh Allen Over 245.5 Passing Yards Over -115
Josh Allen Under 245.5 Passing Yards Under -105

If Allen throws for 246+ yards, the over wins. If he throws for 245 or fewer, the under wins.

Game Props

Bets on specific game events that aren’t tied to the final score:

  • First team to score

  • Will there be overtime? (Yes/No)

  • Total touchdowns in the game

  • Highest-scoring quarter

  • Will both teams score 20+ points?

  • First scoring play type (touchdown, field goal, safety)

Combo / Milestone Props

Some books offer combined stats or milestone-based props:

  • Points + Rebounds + Assists (PRA): A combined stat total for NBA players

  • Anytime touchdown scorer: Player scores at least one touchdown at any point

  • First touchdown scorer: Specific player scores the first TD (high odds, low probability)

  • Player to record a double-double: Two stat categories with 10+ each

How Player Props Are Priced

Sportsbooks set player prop lines based on:

  1. Season averages — the player’s mean performance over the season

  2. Matchup data — opponent’s defensive rankings against that stat category

  3. Recent form — last 5-10 games may be weighted more heavily

  4. Game context — projected game script (blowout risk, pace, weather)

  5. Injuries and lineup changes — teammates being out can increase or decrease a player’s expected usage

The line is usually set near the player’s projected performance for that game, with vig applied to both sides.

Why Props Have More Vig

Player props typically carry more vig than main markets (spreads, totals, moneylines). It’s common to see -115/-115 or even -120/-110 on player props, compared to the standard -110/-110 on spreads.

This happens because:

  • Less liquidity — fewer people bet props, so the book faces more risk per bet

  • Harder to model — individual player performance has more variance than team outcomes

  • Less sharp action — professional bettors focus more on main markets, so there’s less price correction on props

Same-Game Parlays (SGPs)

Same-game parlays combine multiple prop and game bets from a single game into one wager. For example:

  • Chiefs moneyline + Mahomes Over 275.5 passing yards + Travis Kelce Over 5.5 receptions

SGPs are extremely popular because they offer large payouts from small stakes. But there’s an important catch: the sportsbook controls the correlation pricing.

When bets within the same game are correlated (if the Chiefs win, Mahomes probably had a good game), the true parlay odds should be lower than if the bets were independent. The sportsbook decides how to price that correlation, and they typically price it in their favor — meaning the combined odds are worse than the true probability warrants.

SGPs carry some of the highest vig in sports betting, often 15-30%+ above fair odds. They’re an entertainment product, not a sharp betting strategy.

Props vs. Main Markets

Factor Main Markets (Spreads/Totals) Player Props
Vig Lower (~4-5%) Higher (~6-15%)
Sharp attention Heavy Light
Line accuracy Very accurate Less accurate
Variance Lower Higher
Price gaps between books Small (1-3 cents) Large (10-20+ cents)

The higher vig on props is the cost. The benefit: because books pay less attention to props and sharp bettors move less volume there, the lines are less accurate. The price disagreements between books are wider, which means more opportunities for bettors who compare across sportsbooks.

What to Know Before Betting Props

Check the stat counting rules

Different sportsbooks count stats differently. Does a sack count as negative rushing yards? Are overtime stats included? Do you need the player to start, or just play? Read the house rules for props at each book you use.

Injuries and scratches

If a player is ruled out before the game starts, most sportsbooks void the prop and refund the bet. But the rules vary — some books only void if the player doesn’t play at all, not if they leave mid-game with an injury. A quarterback who gets hurt in the first quarter and leaves might not hit his passing yards over, and the bet could still count as a loss.

Alternate lines

Most books offer alternate lines for popular player props. The standard line might be Over 24.5 points at -115, but you could also bet Over 29.5 at +150 or Over 19.5 at -250. Alternate lines let you adjust risk and reward based on your conviction.

Volume adds up

Props are typically lower-limit markets. You might be able to bet $500-$1,000 on an NFL spread but only $250-$500 on a player prop. If you’re betting at scale, prop limits can be a constraint.

Key Takeaways

  • Prop bets are wagers on individual player or game-specific outcomes, not the final score

  • Player props (points, yards, strikeouts) are the most popular and most widely available

  • Props carry higher vig than main markets but also have wider price gaps between sportsbooks

  • Same-game parlays are entertaining but carry massive vig — treat them as fun, not strategy

  • Always check stat counting rules and injury void policies, which vary by sportsbook

  • Compare prop odds across multiple books — the price differences are larger than any other market

  • For an advanced look at finding value in props, see player props as the best +EV market

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a prop bet in sports betting?

A prop bet is a wager on a specific outcome within a game rather than the final result. Common examples include betting on a player's total passing yards, points scored, or strikeouts. Props focus on individual performances or specific game events.

What is the difference between player props and game props?

Player props are bets on individual player statistics like points, yards, or rebounds. Game props are bets on specific game events not tied to the final score, such as which team scores first, whether there will be overtime, or the total number of touchdowns.

Why do player props have higher vig than spreads?

Player props have higher vig because there is less betting volume, individual player performance has more variance than team outcomes, and professional bettors focus less on props. This means sportsbooks face more risk and charge a higher commission to compensate.

Are same-game parlays a good bet?

Same-game parlays are primarily an entertainment product, not a sharp betting strategy. They carry some of the highest vig in sports betting, often 15-30% above fair odds, because the sportsbook controls how correlated outcomes are priced and typically prices them heavily in their favor.

Find +EV bets before they disappear

Optimal Bet scans odds across every major sportsbook and surfaces the +EV opportunities. Stop leaving money on the table.