OPTIMAL and Outlier both cover player props, from opposite ends. Outlier starts from research: hit rates, splits and line movement, with +EV and arbitrage tools on its top plan. OPTIMAL starts from the price: it estimates the true odds, grades every edge from B to A+ and shows the best price across sportsbooks and pick’em apps, with prop projections and research alongside. If you like digging through the numbers yourself, Outlier is a strong pick. If you want the edge found and graded for you, OPTIMAL is.
We make OPTIMAL. Outlier’s side comes from its App Store listing and website, checked November 20, 2026.
New to this? A bet’s edge is how much better its price is than the true odds. Nobody knows the true odds exactly, so every app estimates them. A bet with an edge is +EV (positive expected value): it should come out ahead over many bets, though any single one can lose. A middle, which Outlier offers, means betting both sides at different numbers so both can win if the result lands in between. Our best player props apps guide explains the two kinds of props app: research, or a price.
OPTIMAL vs Outlier at a glance
| OPTIMAL | Outlier | |
|---|---|---|
| Starts from | The price: graded +EV picks | Research: hit rates, splits, line movement |
| +EV picks | Optimal EV, every play graded B to A+ | Positive EV (Pro plan) |
| Sharp books and arbitrage | Sharp Books, Arbitrage | Sharp book odds, arbitrage, middles, boosts (Pro plan) |
| Player prop projections | Floor, projection and ceiling vs the line | Not stated |
| Line shopping | Every major sportsbook and pick’em app | Sportsbooks and prediction markets |
| Pick’em apps | EV Cheat Sheets for PrizePicks, Underdog, Sleeper, Pick6 and more | PrizePicks and Underdog integrations |
| Alerts | A push when a new edge drops | Custom filters and notifications |
| Also in the app | Live scores, play-by-play, fantasy projections, Parlay Builder | Not stated |
| Sports | NFL, NBA, MLB, NHL, WNBA, college football and basketball, MLS, tennis, MMA | NBA, NFL, NHL, NCAAB, NCAAF, MLB, WNBA, soccer |
| Platforms | iOS, Android, web | iOS, Android, web |
| App Store rating | 4.8 (8,406 ratings) | 4.9 (17,146 ratings) |
Where Outlier is stronger
Outlier is a deep research tool with a large, happy user base: more App Store ratings than OPTIMAL at a slightly higher average. Its hit-rate stats, splits and line movement are the core of the app, and its Pro plan adds middles and boosts, which OPTIMAL doesn’t offer. It also covers soccer.
Where OPTIMAL is stronger
OPTIMAL tells you what a line is worth before you research it. Optimal EV compares each line to an estimate of the true odds and grades the edge from B to A+, with the EV, chance to hit and suggested units on every pick. Player prop projections show a floor, projection and ceiling against the line. EV Cheat Sheets do the same for pick’em apps, which don’t show odds at all, ranking picks on PrizePicks, Underdog, Sleeper and Pick6 by edge (Outlier covers PrizePicks and Underdog). And live scores, play-by-play and fantasy projections live in the same app. What OPTIMAL’s grades mean explains how an edge becomes a grade.
Which should you use?
Choose Outlier if research is your process: hit rates, splits and line movement first, with +EV tools when you want them.
Choose OPTIMAL if you want the price first: graded edges, the best book or pick’em app for each, and props projected against the line.
Neither app makes a pick a sure thing. An edge pays off over many bets, and losing nights are part of it.
Key Takeaways
Outlier starts from research (hit rates, splits, line movement) and adds +EV, arbitrage and middles on its top plan.
OPTIMAL starts from the price, grading every edge from B to A+ and showing the best price across sportsbooks and pick’em apps.
OPTIMAL adds prop projections, EV Cheat Sheets for pick’em apps, live scores and fantasy projections.
Outlier has more App Store ratings (17,146 at 4.9) than OPTIMAL (8,406 at 4.8).