HOF and OPTIMAL both help with player props. HOF is a research app: deep stats, hit rates you can slice by opponent, venue or teammates, matchup grades and a parlay optimizer. OPTIMAL estimates the true odds for each line, grades the edge from B to A+ and shows the best price across sportsbooks and pick’em apps. HOF helps you build a case for a prop. OPTIMAL tells you whether the price makes it worth playing.
We make OPTIMAL. HOF’s side comes from its App Store listing, website, FAQ and blog, checked November 21, 2026.
New to this? A bet’s edge is how much better its price is than the true odds. Nobody knows the true odds exactly, so every app estimates them. A bet with an edge is +EV (positive expected value): it should come out ahead over many bets, though any single one can lose. Our best player props apps guide explains the two kinds of props app: research, or a price.
OPTIMAL vs HOF at a glance
| OPTIMAL | HOF | |
|---|---|---|
| Starts from | The price: every play graded B to A+ | Research: stats, hit rates, filters |
| Hit rates | Yes, with Trends for hot streaks | Yes, the core: last 3 to 20 games, season, head-to-head, with or without teammates |
| Edge | Price vs a fair price from the whole market, margin removed | Historical hit rate minus the price’s implied probability |
| Player prop projections | Floor, projection and ceiling vs the line | None listed |
| Matchups | Lineups and injuries next to each prop | Matchup grades by position |
| Line shopping | Every major sportsbook and pick’em app | Odds comparison, pick’em apps included |
| +EV and arbitrage scanning | Optimal EV, Arbitrage, Sharp Books | Not offered, by HOF’s own account |
| Parlays | Parlay Builder with fair odds and the chance it hits | Parlay Optimizer with combined hit rates and correlation |
| Also in the app | Live scores, play-by-play, fantasy projections | Live play-by-play, AI previews, a subscriber Discord |
| Sports | NFL, NBA, MLB, NHL, WNBA, college football and basketball, MLS, tennis, MMA | US leagues, college, and seven soccer leagues plus the World Cup |
| App Store rating | 4.8 (8,407 ratings) | 4.9 (10,848 ratings) |
Where HOF is stronger
HOF’s research filters go deep: how a player does with or without a teammate, against strong or weak defenses at his position, at home or away, over the last 3 to 20 games. Its Parlay Optimizer shows combined hit rates and how correlated the legs are. It covers more soccer than most props apps, includes a Discord community with a subscription, and has more App Store ratings than OPTIMAL at a slightly higher average.
Is a 90% hit rate a 90% chance?
HOF’s own example shows a prop with a 90% hit rate against a 48% implied probability: a 42% “edge”. It’s a fast way to find props worth a look. It isn’t the chance the prop hits.
Ten games is a small sample. A player who truly clears a line 55% of the time will go 8 for 10 or better about one time in ten, just by chance. Across a slate of hundreds of props, dozens will show huge hit rates that are mostly noise, and the price on a real 55% prop might be fair or worse.
That’s why the grade matters. OPTIMAL’s estimate doesn’t come from a 10-game sample. It comes from the market: Optimal EV removes the bookmakers’ margin from the prices at many sportsbooks and blends them into a fair price, then grades a play only when a book pays more than that. A real edge at a sportsbook is usually a few percent, not 42. When a gap looks that big, the hit rate is usually what’s wrong.
Where OPTIMAL fits
Optimal EV grades each play from B to A+ with the EV, chance to hit and suggested units. Prop projections show a floor, projection and ceiling against the line, next to hit rates, lineups and injuries. EV Cheat Sheets rank picks on PrizePicks, Underdog, Sleeper, Pick6 and more by edge, and the Parlay Builder shows a parlay’s fair odds and the chance it hits. See what OPTIMAL’s grades mean.
Which should you use?
Choose HOF if you love the research: situational filters, matchup grades, soccer, and a parlay optimizer.
Choose OPTIMAL if you want each prop priced against an estimate of the true odds and graded, with the best book or pick’em app to play it on.
Neither makes a prop a sure thing. An edge pays off over many bets, not on any one night.
Key Takeaways
HOF is a deep research app: hit rates with situational filters, matchup grades and a parlay optimizer.
HOF’s edge is a hit rate minus the implied probability; OPTIMAL’s is the price against a fair price built from the whole market.
A 10-game hit rate is a small sample: a 55% prop goes 8 for 10 or better about one time in ten.
HOF has more App Store ratings (10,848 at 4.9) than OPTIMAL (8,407 at 4.8).