Up arrow
MLB
Games

New York Mets vs. New York Yankees: Preview, Predictions and Picks for May 18, 2025

Updated on:
May 18, 2025 5:21 PM
The stage is set for a thrilling matchup against the New York Yankees on Sunday, May 18, 2025, at 7:00 PM at Yankee Stadium. With the series tied 1-1, the winner will secure a 3-game series victory. The Mets, currently leading the NL East, will face off against the Yankees, who are on top of the AL East.
New York Mets vs New York Yankees

Current Odds

NYM
NYY
Over
9.0
-108
Under
9.0
+106
NYM
+1.0
+100
NYY
-1.5
+135
NYM
ML
+147
NYY
ML
-152

Mets vs Yankees statistics

Stat Mets Yankees
Hits 382 (Tied-11th) 404 (Tied-5th)
Batting Average .250 (Tied-11th) .262 (3rd)
Runs Batted In 202 (Tied-11th) 248 (3rd)
Runs 210 (Tied-11th) 258 (3rd)
Home Runs 52 (10th) 78 (1st)
Walks 169 (7th) 184 (1st)
Stolen Bases 34 (17th) 33 (Tied-18th)
Strikeouts 348 (Tied-5th) 405 (Tied-25th)
Pitches 6902 (8th) 6980 (4th)

New York Yankees recent games

Game Date Opponent Result Score
5/17/25 vs New York Mets L 3-2
5/16/25 vs New York Mets W 6-2
5/14/25 @ Seattle Mariners W 3-2
5/13/25 @ Seattle Mariners L 2-1 F/11
5/12/25 @ Seattle Mariners W 11-5

New York Mets recent games

Game Date Opponent Result Score
5/17/25 @ New York Yankees W 3-2
5/16/25 @ New York Yankees L 6-2
5/14/25 vs Pittsburgh Pirates L 4-0
5/13/25 vs Pittsburgh Pirates W 2-1
5/12/25 vs Pittsburgh Pirates W 4-3

New York Yankees injuries

  • Brennen Davis (CF): Day-To-Day
  • Spencer Jones (CF): Day-To-Day
  • Scott Effross (RP): 15-Day-IL
  • Giancarlo Stanton (DH): 60-Day-IL
  • JT Brubaker (SP): 60-Day-IL

New York Mets injuries

  • Oliver Ortega (RP): Day-To-Day
  • Paul Blackburn (SP): 15-Day-IL
  • Frankie Montas (SP): 60-Day-IL
  • Yacksel Rios (RP): Day-To-Day
  • Jose Siri (CF): 10-Day-IL

Mets vs Yankees game info

Type Info
Venue Yankee Stadium
Location Bronx, New York
First pitch Sun 7:00 PM
TV ESPN
Temperature 70°
Chance of Rain 5%

Mets vs Yankees predictions

When you look at this Mets squad, it’s hard not to get excited about Pete Alonso stepping up in the big moments. With his power stroke, Alonso always feels like one swing away from getting things rolling, and given his matchup, it wouldn’t be surprising to see him grab an RBI or two tonight. Francisco Lindor is another name you can’t help but watch—his pop at the plate and speed on the bases should set him up nicely. I’d keep an eye on Starling Marte as well; he’s been finding gaps with singles and doesn’t mind flashing that speed with a stolen base if the opportunity comes up. David Peterson will be on the mound, and while he’s capable of keeping hitters off balance and racking up strikeouts, he’ll need to make sure he’s painting the corners to avoid giving up extra-base hits in Yankee Stadium.

On the Yankees’ side, all eyes are on Aaron Judge—seriously, could anyone be hotter right now? Judge has been mashing home runs and seems primed for another multi-hit performance, especially with the way he’s commanding the strike zone and piling up walks. Juan Soto could absolutely make some noise in the heart of the order, drawing walks and driving in runs if Mets pitching loses its control. Max Fried is set to toe the rubber, and with his ability to generate ground balls and keep the damage limited, expect a solid outing. Don't sleep on young guys like Jasson Dominguez, who brings that sneaky speed and power potential, and Anthony Volpe, who should be a spark plug at the top of the lineup, picking up hits and taking an extra bag or two.

With the series tied and both teams battling for bragging rights, it’s shaping up to be the kind of game that keeps you glued to every at-bat. The Yankees’ combination of big bats and home field advantage just gives them that little extra edge. Their ability to grind out at-bats, force walks, and use the long ball in the Bronx might make the difference, even if the Mets jump out early. In this classic New York showdown, I see the Yankees pulling away late and taking the series in front of their home crowd. Yankees fans, get ready—this one has the makings of a memorable win.

New York Yankees

New York Mets

More Games