Up arrow
MLB
Games

New York Yankees vs. Athletics: Preview, Predictions and Picks for May 9, 2025

Updated on:
May 9, 2025 1:35 PM
The Athletics, fresh off a strong outing from Logan Wilson, who tallied four hits, look to build momentum as they host the first-place New York Yankees on Friday at Sutter Health Park. The Yankees, sitting atop the AL East with a 21-16 record, will aim to improve their 8-8 road record. This AL showdown is set to get underway at 10:05 PM ET on Friday, May 9, 2025.
New York Yankees vs Athletics

Current Odds

NYY
ATH
Over
11.0
+105
Under
10.5
+113
NYY
-1.5
+110
ATH
+1.5
-121
NYY
ML
-139
ATH
ML
+135

Yankees vs Athletics statistics

Stat Yankees Athletics
Hits 321 (8th) 336 (5th)
Batting Average .258 (7th) .258 (5th)
Runs Batted In 199 (Tied-3rd) 158 (14th)
Runs 206 (Tied-3rd) 165 (15th)
Home Runs 62 (1st) 47 (8th)
Walks 147 (4th) 116 (Tied-20th)
Stolen Bases 27 (Tied-17th) 17 (29th)
Strikeouts 329 (25th) 281 (5th)
Pitches 5665 (10th) 5303 (23rd)

Athletics recent games

Game Date Opponent Result Score
5/7/25 vs Seattle Mariners L 6-5
5/6/25 vs Seattle Mariners L 5-3
5/5/25 vs Seattle Mariners W 7-6 F/11
5/4/25 @ Miami Marlins W 3-2
5/3/25 @ Miami Marlins L 9-6

New York Yankees recent games

Game Date Opponent Result Score
5/7/25 vs San Diego Padres W 4-3 F/10
5/6/25 vs San Diego Padres W 12-3
5/5/25 vs San Diego Padres L 4-3
5/4/25 vs Tampa Bay Rays L 7-5
5/3/25 vs Tampa Bay Rays L 3-2

Athletics injuries

  • Michel Otanez (RP): 15-Day-IL
  • J.T. Ginn (SP): 15-Day-IL
  • Zack Gelof (2B): 10-Day-IL
  • Ken Waldichuk (SP): 60-Day-IL

New York Yankees injuries

  • DJ LeMahieu (3B): 10-Day-IL
  • Clayton Beeter (RP): 15-Day-IL
  • Brennen Davis (CF): Day-To-Day
  • Marcus Stroman (SP): 15-Day-IL
  • Spencer Jones (CF): Day-To-Day

Yankees vs Athletics game info

Type Info
Venue Sutter Health Park
Location Sacramento, California
First pitch Fri 10:05 PM

Yankees vs Athletics predictions

When the New York Yankees face off against the Athletics, all eyes will be on Aaron Judge. Hitting with an impressive .400 batting average and with a projected hit count of over one per game, Judge is a force at the plate. With a home run projection sitting at a cool 0.3, there’s a good chance he could leave the stadium cheering for yet another one in the books. Meanwhile, Cody Bellinger’s knack for sneaking on base promises to keep the pressure on. His projected singles and walks show his tenacity, ready to bolster the Yankees lineup. Will Warren on the mound will be something to watch closely, too—particularly to see if he secures the victory with his mix of fastballs and strikethrowers.

Turning to the Athletics’ side of things, Jacob Wilson is the hot talk after his spectacular four-hit game. Continuing his winning streak with a batting average not too shabby at .357, Wilson projects to be a consistent threat with the bat, hoping to follow up his recent heroics. Brent Rooker, flexing power with his nine home runs, could potentially add to his stats if the opportunity arises, while Tyler Soderstrom stacks up as another key contributor, poised for RBIs on the base paths. Osvaldo Bido will take the mound, with hopes to neutralize the Yankees' hits and keep the team's energy high. Keeping an eye on how he delivers with his strike power could be a deciding factor in the game.

With both teams toeing the line, predicting a winner feels like a battle of statistics versus surprises. However, the Yankees, with their current standing first in the AL East, seem to bring a slight edge into the game, especially with the consistent powerhouse actions of Judge. Also, playing at Sutter Health Park could see them playing with renewed energy and focus. On the other hand, the Athletics aren’t far behind in the standings and have their own set of stars ready to seize the day. Should Wilson and Rooker get their rhythm going against Warren, it could turn on its head. What do you think? My bet’s on the Yankees clinching this one, but it’s baseball—a game of glorious unpredictables.

Sacramento Athletics

New York Yankees

More Games